On Sunday, Michael Carrick walked off the Old Trafford pitch after a 3-0 home defeat to Bournemouth with United supporters singing his name. By Monday he was in crisis talks with the club’s hierarchy. By Tuesday morning he was back at Carrington taking training, granted what the papers call a stay of execution, with Chelsea away on Saturday.
It is a remarkable swing for a man handed a permanent two-year contract in May after guiding United to third. Two wins in twelve games, a 4-1 Champions League defeat at Como and his captain publicly questioning his tactics changed the mood in a matter of weeks. Asked about his future, Carrick said simply: “I feel the responsibility but we’ll have to wait and see.”
He is not alone. Pierre Sage at Crystal Palace and Frank Lampard at Coventry are both under serious pressure after damaging results. No Premier League manager has lost his job yet this season, but that follows a record 11 in-season managerial changes in 2025/26. As a Spurs supporter, I have watched this particular theatre from the stands more often than I would like.
Having worked inside Premier League dressing rooms and boardrooms during weeks exactly like this one, I want to look past the headlines at two questions. Why does football keep reaching for the same lever? And what does it actually take to stay resilient when your job, your reputation and your livelihood are being debated live on Sky Sports News?
Why are so many Premier League managers losing their jobs?
Managers lose their jobs because they are the most visible and most replaceable part of a system under extreme financial and emotional pressure, and because the people deciding their fate are human. The data tell the story of acceleration. According to the League Managers Association, nine Premier League managers were sacked in 2025/26, with an average tenure of just 0.89 years, the shortest in its records going back to 2013/14.
Three psychological forces sit underneath those numbers.
1. Action bias. When things go wrong, doing something feels better than doing nothing, even when doing nothing is the smarter move. The best evidence for this comes from football itself. Bar-Eli and colleagues analysed 286 elite penalty kicks and found that goalkeepers stayed in the centre only 6.3% of the time, despite stopping roughly a third of kicks when they did, about twice their success rate when diving. The explanation is norm theory: a goal conceded while standing still feels worse, and is judged more harshly, than one conceded mid-dive. Owners are goalkeepers facing a penalty. Sacking the manager is the dive.
2. Outcome bias. We judge decisions by their results rather than by the quality of the thinking behind them. Professor Jan van Ours of Erasmus School of Economics, writing in the Journal of Economic Psychology, found that clubs in Europe’s top leagues consistently dismiss managers for the wrong reasons, often after runs of bad luck rather than genuinely poor performance. A deflected shot, a VAR decision and a missed sitter can rewrite a manager’s reputation in a fortnight.
3. The scapegoat. Sociologists have described the sacking as a ritual since the 1960s. It is far easier to remove one person than to rebuild a squad of 25, restructure a recruitment department or admit a strategic error at board level. The manager absorbs the collective anxiety of owners, players and supporters, and his removal releases it, at least for a while.
Add the financial cliff edges at both ends of the table, where survival or Champions League qualification can be worth tens of millions, and the pressure to be seen to act becomes almost irresistible.
Does sacking the manager actually work?
Mostly, no. The famous “new manager bounce” is largely a statistical illusion called regression to the mean: teams that have been unusually unlucky tend to drift back towards their normal level, whoever is in the dugout.
The evidence is consistent across countries and decades:
- Netherlands. Bas ter Weel studied 18 seasons of the Eredivisie (1986 to 2004) and concluded that the bounce is nothing more than regression to the mean.
- England. Dr Sue Bridgewater of Warwick Business School found that clubs typically sack a manager when averaging about one point per game, the low point of a natural cycle. Three months later, the typical club was back to around 1.3 points per game, roughly where it would have been anyway.
- The honeymoon fades. Bridgewater’s later analysis for the LMA found a short-term gain of around 2.5 points for Premier League clubs, followed by a dip roughly 12 games later to a level below that achieved before the change.
- Europe’s top leagues. Van Ours found the same pattern: underperforming teams improved in subsequent matches whether or not the manager was replaced. His conclusion was that keeping faith after a run of bad luck is frequently the more rational choice.
To be fair to the other side, some studies, including Lago-Peñas’s work on Spanish football, do find a short-term points gain after a change. Not every sacking follows bad luck, and a genuinely broken dressing room can be repaired by new leadership. But the weight of evidence says the manager’s influence is routinely overestimated in both directions, in victory and in defeat.
Which raises the more interesting question. If results swing on luck far more than we admit, then the real test of a leader is not the run itself. It is how they think, behave and lead while it is happening.
What does resilience look like under extreme pressure?
Resilience is not the absence of stress. It is the way a person appraises stress and what they do next. The clearest evidence comes from David Fletcher and Mustafa Sarkar at Loughborough, who interviewed 12 Olympic champions about withstanding pressure across their careers.
They found five psychological factors that protected the world’s best athletes from the damaging effects of stress:
- A positive personality, including openness, conscientiousness, competitiveness, optimism and proactivity
- Motivation, drawn from both internal and external sources
- Confidence
- Focus
- Perceived social support
The crucial finding is how these factors work. They do not stop pressure arriving. They change how the performer interprets it, steering them towards a challenge appraisal rather than a threat appraisal. The champions judged external pressure as important, and chose to perform in demanding environments anyway.
This fits the theory of challenge and threat states developed by Jones, Meijen, McCarthy and Sheffield. When we believe our resources match the demands in front of us, the body mobilises for performance. When we believe the demands outstrip our resources, the same pressure becomes threat: narrower attention, poorer decisions and a retreat into self-protection. Same scoreline, entirely different nervous system.
A follow-up study by Sarkar, Fletcher and Brown with ten Olympic gold medallists found something even more striking. Adversity was described as vital to their development, not merely survived. Setbacks drove their motivation and learning.
Carrick himself has lived this. He was sacked by Middlesbrough in 2025, then returned to Old Trafford as interim manager and won three in a row against Manchester City, Arsenal and Fulham. In February, asked about his future, his answer was a textbook statement of controllables: he could not control who got the job, and it would not change what he did or how he felt. Whatever happens at Stamford Bridge on Saturday, that is the right psychological posture.
How do you stay resilient when your job is on the line?
You shrink the horizon, separate process from outcome, and protect the people around you. None of these is a slogan. Each is a deliberate strategy, and strategy beats positivity every time.
Shrink the horizon. When West Ham asked me to come in, the club was bottom of the league, ten points from safety with ten games to go. Nobody could hold “stay up” in their head without it turning into threat. So we broke the final nine games into three blocks of three, with a floor target of five points per block. Five points from three games feels achievable. Survival from bottom does not. The squad took 21 points from 27, a 78% return against 23% before. The goal had not changed. The size of the next step had.
Restore the sense of control. Martin Seligman’s work on learned helplessness shows what repeated setbacks can do: people stop believing their effort affects the outcome, and they stop trying. A losing run does this to dressing rooms. The leader’s job is to reconnect effort with result, through small, controllable targets that people can see themselves hitting.
Judge the process, not just the scoreline. If outcome bias drives the boardroom, the antidote in the dressing room is a clear definition of a good performance that does not depend on a deflection. Leaders who review decisions, not just results, keep their judgement intact when the table is lying to them.
Expect adversity, and rehearse the “what ifs”. Resilient performers do not hope the bad moment will not come. They plan for it. What if we concede first? What if the crowd turns? What if the board calls on Monday? A rehearsed response is a resource, and resources are what turn threat back into challenge.
Protect perceived support, and allow honesty. Fletcher and Sarkar list social support as a core protective factor. In my experience it must include the freedom to say uncomfortable things. During that West Ham run, the turning point in one team meeting came from Dean Ashton, injured all season, standing up and naming the squad’s lack of professionalism. Support is not comfort. It is a group that can tell itself the truth.
For how teams build this before the pressure arrives, and what the research says about resilience in leadership, see Resilience in leadership: what football’s managerial merry-go-round really teaches us.
What can business leaders learn from the Premier League sack race?
Every organisation runs its own version of the sack race, just without the live television. Quarterly targets are the league table. The board is the owner. And action bias, outcome bias and scapegoating operate in the boardroom exactly as they do at a football club.
Three lessons travel well:
- For those under pressure: your resilience is built before the crisis, not during it. The habits that protect you (a challenge mindset, controllable targets, rehearsed responses, honest relationships) have to be in place when the run starts, because a bad run is the worst possible time to learn them.
- For those making the decisions: before you dive, ask whether you are reacting to bad luck or bad leadership. Regression to the mean will flatter whoever comes next. Sometimes the bravest decision is to stand in the centre of the goal.
- For teams: pressure exposes culture. Teams that can tell themselves the truth, and pull together rather than apart, give any leader a far better chance. That is the heart of my work on winning teams: the recurring patterns of behaviour that separate groups who hold together under pressure from those who fragment.
Some of the most psychologically astute managers I have worked with, Steve Coppell among them, shared one quality above all others. They kept the scoreboard in perspective without ever pretending it did not matter. That balance, caring deeply about results while refusing to be ruled by them, is what I call the winning mind.
Work with Roberto
Booking a speaker? The Winning Mind explores how elite performers think, decide and recover under pressure, drawing on work inside Premier League clubs, Grand Slam tennis and Olympic sport. Enquire about speaking
Building a team that holds together under pressure? Inside Winning Teams workshops translate the recurring patterns of behaviour behind high-performing teams into practical habits for leadership groups. Talk about performance psychology support
Producer or journalist? Roberto is available for expert comment on pressure, resilience and the psychology of football management. Media enquiries
Sources
- Man Utd make final Michael Carrick sack decision ahead of Chelsea (GiveMeSport, 27 Oct 2026)
- Michael Carrick keeps his job (AOL, 27 Oct 2026)
- Premier League sack race: Carrick, Sage and Lampard ranked (Dave Sport, 26 Oct 2026)
- LMA: over 200 managers and coaching staff sacked in 2025/26 (Gazette, May 2026)
- Bar-Eli et al. (2007) Action bias among elite soccer goalkeepers, Journal of Economic Psychology
- BPS Research Digest on the goalkeeper study
- Van Ours: Outcome bias in managerial decisions (Erasmus School of Economics)
- Ter Weel and the new manager bounce (Soccer Analytics)
- Soccernomics on Bridgewater’s sacking research (FourFourTwo)
- LMA on short-termism and the honeymoon effect (Yorkshire Post)
- Lago-Peñas (2007) on coaching changes in Spanish football
- Fletcher and Sarkar (2012) A grounded theory of psychological resilience in Olympic champions
- Sarkar, Fletcher and Brown (2015) What doesn’t kill me
- Carrick on not rushing the manager decision (Malay Mail, Feb 2026)
Header photo: Lars Bo Nielsen on Unsplash.

